This Week in Shenzhen: The Xi-Trump-Putin Show

November 16, 2026
In September, when Kremlin officials leaked that Russian President Vladimir Putin was expecting a three-way summit with Donald Trump and host Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the Shenzhen, China, APEC meeting in November, gasps echoed across NATO capitals.
Would this be a throwback to the three-power Yalta conference in January 1945, when Stalin convinced an ailing Roosevelt to divide up Europe?
The wild card in the Shenzhen arrangement is Russia, which is hardly any longer a great power.
But US backers assert that the trilateral rationale permits a vital opportunity for the three biggest possessors of strategic nuclear arms to discuss disarmament. Cooperation to end Iran’s successful oil ransom strategy is another US meeting objective.
Host Xi Jinping is quite satisfied with the way the world is going, what with the US and Russia bogged down in losing and costly wars against Iran and Ukraine. On nuclear weapons, Xi intends to pursue China’s strong drive to reach par with the other two, so has no interest in a nuclear freeze applying to China.
On Iran, though, China is the biggest importer of Iranian oil, it retains ample reserves, while its successful pivot to green energy leads the world.
China no doubt views the US today as a depleting power with a diminished leader. Even the American A.I. industry risks derailment from the Nvidia shambles (that Chinese intelligence may have prompted).
But for reasons of Chinese economic momentum, Xi wants a stable relationship with the US, so seems content to string Trump along to a three-way meeting without a substantive outcome.
For Putin, however, the threesome show provides special rewards: break-out from the diplomatic isolation and sanctions that followed the invasion of Ukraine; progress in breaking the Atlantic alliance in two; and intimation of attainment of Putin’s sweetest dream of all — the positioning of Russia as one of three Great Powers.
In reality, Russia qualifies only as a nuclear power. Even the relationship between China and Russia is defined by Beijing’s subordination of an increasingly dependent Moscow.
Still, there is a geopolitical shade to the pretence.
Eighteen months ago, Michael Ignatieff warned of the re-emergence of a world defined by great power “spheres of influence” to supplant the postwar international rules-based order fashioned under US leadership that Putin had resented for decades and that Donald Trump has decided to trash.
Trump and Putin, in their disdain for democracy, their ignorance, their fathomless arrogance, and their authoritarian presumption, apparently imagine a world ruled by “might is right”.
Trump’s new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, asserted (to CNN’s Jake Tapper) as much in January when he was still deputy chief of staff. “We live in a world in which you can talk all you want about international niceties and everything else,” Miller said on the White House lawn. “But we live in a world, in the real world … that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power. These are the iron laws of the world since the beginning of time.”
Trump and Putin, in their disdain for democracy, their ignorance, their fathomless arrogance, and their authoritarian presumption, apparently imagine a world ruled by ‘might is right’.
Putin’s vengeful animosity to a Western world that he considers has disrespected him has been clear for two decades. After the invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov admitted in an interview that the real goal of the war was to end America’s geopolitical dominance.
As Canada’s Ambassador to Russia, I witnessed how Ex-KGB officer Putin tried as a Vice-Mayor of St. Petersburg in the early 1990s to pose as a democrat, but with no grasp of the behavioural obligations of democracy.
After he catapulted to Russia’s presidency on New Year’s Day 2000, his inherent resentments and residual KGB habits of mind took a few years to surface. Though George W. Bush spied his “soul” early on, Putin’s view of America darkened in response to the lawless US invasion of Iraq in 2003, American support for “colour” revolutions in the former Soviet Union and the Balkans, its denunciation of Russian military action against breakaway Chechnya and, in 2008, Georgia.
In the end, the power of rampant, state-sponsored corruption proved more determinative in a struggling post-communist state than the power of democracy.
In 2007, Putin had warned the Munich Security Conference that Russia “would no longer accept its assigned role as subordinate” in a “unipolar world” dominated by an America that behaved as it wished. After Putin returned to the presidency in 2012, the pro-Europe uprising in Ukraine against the Russian-supported candidate for president drove him to grab Crimea and Russian-speaking Ukrainian provinces in the Donbas.
In 2014, President Obama delivered the gravest insult to Putin’s self-esteem when he described Russia as “a regional power that is threatening some of its immediate neighbours not out of strength but out of weakness.”
Putin’s recourse has been to promote a concocted historic vocation for Russia as an Orthodox “civilizational state” whose credibility he must presume will be enhanced by the Shenzhen Summit with the hegemonic Chinese host and their “Don-roe doctrine” US counterpart.
Putin will work the Ukraine war and its settlement into the trilateral discussion if he can. Ukrainian President Zelensky reported this week that Trump’s Russia-inclined and history-averse negotiator and son-in-law Jared Kushner proposed to him that Ukraine cede all of the Donbas to Russia in exchange for the right to join NATO.
But a Kremlin spokesman simultaneously stated that Russia again insists that NATO limit its military footprint to member states that preceded NATO expansion that began in 1997. There is no end to the illegal war in sight.
In the end, the Shenzhen trilateral may prove to have been just another photo-op in the lame-duck stretch of the receding Trump era.
Policy Columnist Jeremy Kinsman served as Canada’s ambassador to Russia, high commissioner to the UK, ambassador to Italy and ambassador to the European Union. He is a Distinguished Fellow of the Canadian International Council.
