Is an Interim Tariff Deal a Good Idea? That Depends.

 

By Anil Wasif

November 20, 2026

Canada wants an interim tariff arrangement with the United States by the end of the year, CBC News reported on Thursday, after Dominic LeBlanc briefed the government’s advisory committee on the talks.

Three days after that target, on January 3rd, a new Congress takes office in Washington, and some Democrats in it have pledged to try to end the tariffs on Canadian goods.

If Washington does move, the test of the deal is the tariff it leaves on autos.

Flavio Volpe, the president of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers’ Association and a member of the committee, asked on CBC whether this is the best time to do a deal. That depends on which tariffs the deal is for.

The new Congress or the courts may lift one set of them without Canada giving anything up. The other set is larger, is likely to outlast the new Congress, and includes a tariff that doubles two days before its members arrive.

LeBlanc described the two sets on CBC’s Power & Politics on Thursday. Canada wants the United States to lower the tariffs it charges in the name of national security, under Section 232 of a 1962 trade law, on steel, aluminum, autos and lumber.

And it wants the 50% tariffs that took effect in August on hundreds of Canadian goods, under Section 338 of a 1930 law, removed entirely.

The Americans have been clear, Leblanc said, that an arrangement on those tariffs would also let the formal review of the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA)begin. The United States declined to renew that agreement on July 1st.

“We have to be realistic with Canadians,” LeBlanc said. In the Section 232 sectors, “an element of those tariffs” is going to remain.

The Section 338 tariffs are the ones Canada may see lifted without paying for it. They apply to about $20 billion USD of Canadian goods, per the Associated Press.

Opposition to tariffs on Canada crosses party lines in Congress. The Senate passed resolutions against them in April and October of last year, and the House passed one in February, with Republicans voting alongside Democrats each time.

Those votes removed nothing, because the president can veto a resolution and an override takes two-thirds of both chambers. But Ron Wyden, the senior Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, sees ending the Section 338 tariffs as the issue most likely to win Republican votes, the Associated Press reported.

“That’s what we’re focused on, figuring out a way to beat Trump and his veto,” Wyden, who will be Senate Finance chair when the Democrats take over, told the AP.

Alan Wolff of the Peterson Institute for International Economics wrote this month that a bill aimed at the Canada tariffs has a better chance of surviving a veto than any broader one. His colleague Inu Manak reached the same view. Neither called it certain. A food importer in New Jersey has also sued over the tariffs.

The president’s first tariffs on Canada ended that way in February, when the US Supreme Court ruled that the emergency law behind them did not authorize tariffs.

Any interim deal should be judged on its Section 232 terms. LeBlanc’s own measure is ‘a better comparative position’ than the countries that already have deals.

The Section 232 tariffs are the larger burden, and none of those analysts predicts the same for them. Wolff expects the president to veto any exemption for Canada. The Council on Foreign Relations concluded the day after the midterms that tariff policy will stay largely in the president’s hands.

LeBlanc said Canada should not count on the new Congress as a “magic bullet.”

These are also the tariffs with a date on them. Donald Trump said in August that the tariff on Canadian cars, trucks and auto parts will rise to 50% from 25% on January 1. The terms of the new Congress begin at noon on January 3. A deal reached in December would stop that increase before it starts. Nothing the new Congress is expected to do would.

So, the interim deal should be judged on its Section 232 terms. LeBlanc’s own measure is “a better comparative position” than the countries that already have deals. The European Union, Japan and South Korea each accepted 15% on autos, by the Council on Foreign Relations’ count in March, and Britain 10% on a fixed number of cars.

Colin Robertson wrote in Policy in August that Canada and the United States had discussed 15% as well, and that a deal that only cancelled the Section 338 tariffs “would be welcome, but insufficient.” That holds more strongly now that the Section 338 tariffs are the ones most likely to be lifted by someone else.

Whatever Canada concedes should buy relief on steel, aluminum, autos and lumber.

Lumber shows the limit even of that. LeBlanc named it among the sectors where the Section 232 tariff would come down. The United States charges almost 35% on Canadian softwood, and the Section 232 tariff is 10 points of that.

The rest are anti-dumping and countervailing duties, which come from a different law and which American lumber companies have pursued for decades. They are not among the tariffs LeBlanc said the deal would lower.

The Institute for Research on Public Policy (IRPP) estimates that as many as 119,000 Canadian jobs are at risk from American tariffs, more of them in wood than in any other industry. On the terms LeBlanc described, most of the duty on softwood stays.

The new Congress matters more for what comes after January. The American law that put CUSMA into force requires the president to consult two congressional committees before each review, and the Congressional Research Service notes that any revision that changes American law needs legislation from Congress.

LeBlanc says an interim arrangement is what opens that review. A deal in December would bring Canada to the stage where Congress has a formal role.

John Weekes argued in Policy last December that Canada should not rush into a deal, and that American political pressure would move trade policy in its favour over time. That patience may yet be rewarded on the Section 338 tariffs, though it does nothing about the auto tariff due on January 1.

Reuters has reported, citing two people familiar with LeBlanc’s briefing, that the United States has shown little movement since talks broke down in August, and that the midterms have not changed the course of the talks.

“We’d like to do a deal,” Mark Carney told the Dealbook conference by video from China on November 18th. “If the U.S. doesn’t want to do a deal, we’re busy.”

Policy Columnist Anil Wasif is a public servant in the Ontario government. He serves on the University of Toronto’s Governing Council and the Advisory Board of McGill’s Max Bell School. Internationally, he serves on the OECD’s Infrastructure Delivery Committee and the Board of Trustees at BacharLorai Global. The views expressed are his own.